|
Atonement (2007, US/UK)
In director Joe Wright's epic war film of thwarted
romance over a period of six decades:
- the three scenes of fantasy-prone 13 year-old aspiring
writer Briony Tallis (Saoirse Ronan) witnessing a series of events
in 1935 England - with long-lasting consequences that caused irrevocable
and permanent damage:
(1) she watched as her lithe older sister Cecilia Tallis
(Keira Knightley) cavorted with her 'secret' boyfriend, servant/cook
son Robbie Turner (James McAvoy) at her rich family's estate at an
outdoor fountain; she saw Cecilia dive underwater to retrieve a broken
piece of a family heirloom vase - and emerged almost naked in front
of Robbie with her soaked and transparent dress
(2) she also observed their passionate love-making scene against
the stacks in the library
(3) she saw house-guest Paul Marshall (Benedict
Cumberbatch) and her 15 year-old visiting cousin Lola Quincey (Juno Temple)
engaged in rough, 'non-consensual rape'
- afterwards, however, Briony
(willfully?) misidentified and wrongly accused Robbie of 'raping'
Lola; Robbie was charged and arrested for the 'rape'
- four years later, Robbie had been pardoned and
was serving in the British Army, where he was a participant in
the Dunkirk evacuation, and had become seriously wounded
- a bravura extended tracking shot (5 minutes and
30 seconds) showed Robbie walking along the French beach during the
Dunkirk evacuation - where stranded show horses were being executed,
as the camera glided down the beach (amidst a beached barge and a
spinning ferris wheel) and then around a choir of wounded infantrymen,
and ended finally in a bar
- at the same time, Cecilia was a nurse during the war
effort, while 18 year-old Briony (Romola Garai) was working in a
London hospital. When Briony realized that she had testified falsely
about Robbie's involvement with Lola, she went to apologize to them,
but it appeared too late to have any effect
- at film's end in present-day England, older, terminally-ill
(with vascular dementia) novelist Briony (Vanessa Redgrave) was interviewed
about her latest and last book - an autobiographical work
titled Atonement -
when she confessed as an act of penance that much of the end portion
of the novel (concerning her apology) was fabricated and imaginary
about their reconciliation, since both Robbie and Cecilia died during
the war; Robbie had died of a sepsis infection at Dunkirk
before being evacuated, and Cecilia drowned as a result of a
tube station bombing during the Blitz months later
|
|
Older Novelist Briony (Vanessa Redgrave): Her
Confession
|
Her Novel's Fabricated Happy Ending
|
- the final idealized scene (a 'happy ending') of
the lovers cavorting on the beach near a beach house, was as Briony
stated: "So
in the book, I wanted to give Robbie and Cecilia what they lost
out on in life. I'd like to think this isn't weakness or evasion,
but a final act of kindness. I gave them their happiness"
|
Sexy Fountain Scene
Library Love-Making Against Stacks
Robbie Wrongly Accused of 'Raping' Lola
Young Briony Tallis (Saoirse Ronan): Her Fanciful Accusatory
Imagination
Dunkirk Evacuation Scene
|