1941
The winner is listed first, in CAPITAL letters.
Actor:
GARY COOPER in "Sergeant York", Cary Grant in "Penny
Serenade", Walter Huston in "All That Money Can Buy",
Robert Montgomery in "Here Comes Mr. Jordan", Orson
Welles in "Citizen
Kane"
Actress:
JOAN FONTAINE in "Suspicion", Bette Davis in "The
Little Foxes", Olivia de Havilland in "Hold Back the
Dawn", Greer Garson in "Blossoms in the Dust",
Barbara Stanwyck in "Ball of Fire"
Supporting Actor:
DONALD CRISP in "How Green Was My Valley",
Walter Brennan in "Sergeant York", Charles Coburn in "The
Devil and Miss Jones", James Gleason in "Here Comes
Mr. Jordan", Sydney Greenstreet in "The
Maltese Falcon"
Supporting Actress:
MARY ASTOR in "The Great Lie", Sara Allgood in "How
Green Was My Valley", Patricia Collinge in "The
Little Foxes", Teresa Wright in "The Little Foxes",
Margaret Wycherly in "Sergeant York"
Director:
JOHN FORD for "How Green Was My Valley",
Alexander Hall for "Here Comes Mr. Jordan", Howard
Hawks for "Sergeant York", Orson Welles for "Citizen
Kane", William Wyler for "The Little Foxes"
Documentaries
were a new category that was added in 1941 (with the Oscar
given to Churchill's Island from the Canadian Film Board
(and UA), the first of several consecutive WWII documentaries
to win in the same category). The Academy Awards ceremony for
1941 was held only a few months after the bombing of Pearl
Harbor, on February 26, 1942. Soon, the Hollywood community
would rally to boost morale and provide entertainment for the
troops. Carole Lombard died in a tragic plane crash about a
month before the Oscar ceremony, on January 16, 1942, after
a War Bond rally tour appearance.
The Best Picture winner was John Ford's populist,
sentimental tale spanning fifty years of an impoverished and
disintegrating Welsh mining town and family that was based
on Richard Llewellyn's best-selling novel, How
Green Was My Valley (with ten nominations and five
wins - Best Picture, Best Supporting Actor (Crisp), Best Director,
Best B/W Cinematography by Arthur Miller, and Best Art Direction).
Through the eyes of young son Huw (Roddy McDowall), the episodic
life (including crises such as strikes and mine disasters,
and joys) of the close-knit Morgan family and Welsh coal-mining
community were remembered in the narrative. [In the previous
year, Ford had directed another Oscar-nominated family saga, The
Grapes of Wrath (1940).]
The other nominees for Best Picture included
two debut films for its directors, two films with nine nominations
each, and one film with eleven nominations:
- director/writer John Huston's debut film
- a fast-paced film noir/mystery based upon Dashiell Hammett's
tale
The
Maltese Falcon (with three nominations for Best Picture,
Best Supporting Actor, and Best Screenplay, and no wins),
about a search for an elusive Black Bird. This masterpiece
is considered one of the greatest detective/film-noir classics
ever made, but it did not win a single award in any
of its three nominated categories
- director/actor/producer/writer Orson Welles' first
feature film -
Citizen
Kane (with nine nominations and only one win -
the only award that the film won was Best Original
Screenplay (by Henry J. Mankiewicz and Orson Welles) -
it should have won the Best Picture award); it is generally
acknowledged to be the greatest film ever made by critics
and film-fans - an intriguing tale about a newspaper publisher/tycoon
from his early childhood to his lonely death, told in a
series of flashbacks
[Twenty five year-old "boy genius" Welles was the first to
ever receive simultaneous nominations in four categories: as
producer, actor, director, and writer. The previous year, Charlie
Chaplin was the first to ever receive three simultaneous
nominations, as producer, actor, and screenwriter for The
Great Dictator (1940).]
- director William Wyler's filming of Lillian
Hellman's own play script, The Little Foxes (with
nine nominations and no wins!) about a vicious and destructive
Southern matriarch
- director Hitchcock's thrilling tale Suspicion (with
three nominations and one win - Best Actress) about a newlywed
bride fearful of her wealthy new husband
- director Howard Hawks' true story of a country
boy who becomes a great WWI hero in Sergeant York (with
eleven nominations and two wins - Best Actor and Best Film
Editing)
- director Mervyn LeRoy's filming of Anita Loos'
screenplay about an orphanage founder, Blossoms in the
Dust (with four nominations and one win - Best Color
Interior Decoration)
- director Alexander Hall's romantic fantasy Here
Comes Mr. Jordan (with seven nominations and two wins
- Best Original Story and Best Screenplay) about a heavenly
mixup and a prizefighter's body-switch [This film served
as the inspiration for director/actor Warren Beatty's Best
Picture-nominated Heaven Can Wait (1978), originally
filmed by director Ernst Lubitsch as the Best Picture-nominated Heaven
Can Wait (1943)]
- director Mitchell Leisen's romance Hold
Back the Dawn (with six nominations and no wins) from
a screenplay by Billy Wilder and Charles Brackett
- director Irving Rapper's tale of a turn-of-the-century
minister in One Foot in Heaven (with one nomination
and no wins)
Even more surprising was that Ford (celebrating
his twenty-fifth anniversary in the film industry) also won
for Best Director - it was his third Best Director Award
and his second Oscar in a row. (He won previous awards for The
Informer (1935) and The
Grapes of Wrath (1940).) [Ford would win one more time
eleven years later for The
Quiet Man (1952).] John Huston wasn't nominated for
Best Director, but he was nominated for his Screenplay for The
Maltese Falcon. Competing Best Director nominee William
Wyler's film The Little Foxes was his sixth film
in a row to receive a Best Picture nomination without winning.
The previous five films were Dodsworth
(1936), Dead End (1937), Jezebel
(1938), Wuthering
Heights (1939), and The Letter
(1940). It was also Wyler's fourth Best Director
nomination in six years without winning - he was nominated
in 1936, 1939, 1940, and 1941. [Wyler's first of three
Best Director career wins came in 1942, for Mrs. Miniver.]
In keeping with the times, Gary Cooper (with
his second nomination) won his first Best Actor award
for his performance as deeply religious backwoods Tennessee
Cumberland Mountains farmer and World War I hero Sergeant Alvin
C. York in Howard Hawks' morale booster Sergeant York.
Cooper's whimsical performance defeated greater epic performances
by the following actors:
- Orson Welles (with his sole acting nomination
in his career!) as the Hearst-like Charles Foster Kane in
Citizen
Kane
- Cary Grant (with his first of two unsuccessful
career nominations) as newspaperman and adoptive father Roger
Adams in director George Stevens' tragic tear-jerker Penny
Serenade (the film's sole nomination) - [Grant's only
two nominations were for serious dramatic roles (the other
was for None But The Lonely Heart (1944)), instead
of for his wildly-popular comedies, including The
Awful Truth (1937),
Bringing
Up Baby (1938), Holiday (1938), and His
Girl Friday (1940).]
- Robert Montgomery (with his second and final
unsuccessful nomination) as prizefighter Joe Pendleton who
is mistakenly sent to heaven and then returns to earth in
the body of a soon-to-be murdered millionaire in Here
Comes Mr. Jordan
- and Walter Huston (with his third nomination)
as the Devil (Mr. Scratch) who bargains with a farmer's soul
and orator Daniel Webster in director William Dieterle's All
That Money Can Buy (with two nominations and one win
- Best Dramatic Picture Score)
In the Best Actress category, two sisters were
rivals for awards:
- Joan Fontaine (with her second nomination
in the second consecutive year for another
Rebecca
(1940) -like role) as a shy, spinsterish British
girl named Lina McLaidlaw (suspicious of and plagued by her
new husband, Cary Grant, and a glass of milk) in Hitchcock's
mystery Suspicion
- and her older sister Olivia de Havilland (with
her second nomination) as schoolteacher Emmy Brown (involved
in an immigration-marriage scam and in love with Charles
Boyer) in the soap Hold Back the Dawn
Fontaine won her first Oscar, probably
as consolation for the previous year's loss. Both roles were
as a victimized young bride. [Her win was the only Best
Actress award ever for a Hitchcock film. De Havilland
would win twice in the 1940s for: To Each His Own (1946) and The
Heiress (1949).]
Other Best Actress nominees included Barbara
Stanwyck (with her second of four unsuccessful career nominations
from 1937-1948 - she never won!) as burlesque nightclub dancer
and gangster moll Sugarpuss O'Shea in director Howard Hawks' Ball
of Fire (with four nominations and no wins), Greer Garson
(with her second nomination - and the first of five consecutive
nominations) as Texas orphanage founder Edna Gladney in Blossoms
in the Dust, and Bette Davis (with her fifth nomination
- and the fourth of five consecutive nominations) as Southern
schemer Regina Giddens in The Little Foxes.
Donald Crisp (with his sole career nomination)
won the Best Supporting Actor award (it was the only Oscar
of his long, fifty-five year career) for his role as the stern
father of the closely-knit Morgan family of Welsh miners, who
is killed in the mine in the film's conclusion in How
Green Was My Valley. Another nominee - Sydney Greenstreet
(with his sole career nomination in his 'talking' film debut
at age 61), nominated for his performance as obsessed, statuette
searcher "Fat Man" Casper Gutman in The
Maltese Falcon, was equally deserving. The other nominees
were Walter Brennan (with his fourth and last nomination -
the only nomination in his career which wasn't a winner) as
village Pastor Rosier Pile in Sergeant York, Charles
Coburn (with his first nomination) as the world's richest man/department
store owner John P. Merrick (who masquerades as a salesclerk)
in director Sam Wood's romantic comedy The Devil and Miss
Jones (with two nominations and no wins), and James Gleason
(with his sole career nomination) as co-star Robert Montgomery's
boxer/manager Max Corkle in Here Comes Mr. Jordan.
Mary Astor (with her sole career nomination)
won the Best Supporting Actress award and her first and
only Oscar for her performance as Sandra Kovak - a sharp-tongued,
selfish and ambitious concert pianist who gives away her baby
(when befriended by Bette Davis, wife of her former lover George
Brent) in The Great Lie (the film's sole nomination).
The defeated nominees included two co-stars from The Little
Foxes: Teresa Wright (with her first nomination in her
debut performance) as Alexandra Giddens (daughter of co-stars
Bette Davis and Herbert Marshall), and Patricia Collinge (with
her sole nomination) as Aunt Birdie Hubbard. The remaining
nominees were Sara Allgood (with her sole career nomination)
as the loving, supportive, and gentle mother figure Mrs. Morgan
in How Green Was My Valley,
and Margaret Wycherley (with her sole career nomination) as
devoted Mother York in Sergeant York.
Disney won another Short Subject: Cartoon Oscar
for Lend a Paw - his ninth win in the category. Leopold
Stokowski received a Special Award for "unique achievement
in the creation of a new form of visualized music"
in Walt Disney's technologically-innovative production of Fantasia -
a big commercial flop at the time. The film's innovators (Walt
Disney, William Garity, John N.A. Hawkins, and the RCA Manufacturing
Company) also won a second Special Award for "their outstanding
contribution to the advancement of the use of sound in motion
pictures."
Oscar Snubs and Omissions:
Barbara Stanwyck's and Henry Fonda's performances
in Sturges' The
Lady Eve went unrecognized.
Peter Lorre and Humphrey Bogart (as cool, yet
tough-talking anti-hero detective Sam Spade) weren't nominated
for their work in John Huston's film-noirish mystery The
Maltese Falcon. [In fact, Peter Lorre was never nominated
for an Oscar.] Bogart had another amazing non-nominated performance
also this year, as Roy "Mad Dog" Earle in Raoul Walsh's
classic gangster film High Sierra (with no nominations).
And Mary Astor, who won for The Great Lie, is better
remembered (and would have preferred to have been nominated
and victorious) for the murderous femme fatale Brigid
O'Shaughnessy in The
Maltese Falcon.
Although there was no Oscar awards category for
Best Makeup until 1981, Citizen
Kane was remarkable in the way that its characters
aged from start to finish. And although the film had nine nominations,
only one was in an acting category (Best Actor for Orson Welles).
Others who had notable performances included: Joseph Cotten
as Jedediah Leland, Dorothy Comingore as Susan Alexander, Everett
Sloane as Mr. Bernstein, and George Coulouris as Walter Parks
Thatcher. Another unforgivable omission was denying the award
of Best B/W Cinematography to nominee Gregg Toland for the
film's marvelous photography.
Howard Hawks' Ball of Fire and Alexander
Korda's That Hamilton Woman were not included in the
group of Best Picture nominees. Vivien Leigh's performance
in That Hamilton Woman was also unnominated. Although
Gary Cooper won Best Actor for Sergeant York, he had two other
equally important hits in 1941 without nominations: Ball
of Fire, and Meet John Doe.
Bernard Herrmann who wrote some of the most dramatic
film scores in the history of cinema (Welles' Citizen
Kane, The
Magnificent Ambersons (1942), Hitchcock's Rear
Window (1954), Vertigo
(1958), North
By Northwest (1959) and Psycho
(1960), and Scorsese's Taxi
Driver (1976)) won his only Oscar in 1941 for
Best Scoring of a Dramatic Picture - All That Money Can
Buy.
|